It's tricky to answer that without poking and prodding he wood. Thinned sealer is good (thinned about 50/50), but pre-turn to a full shape, seal, and then take the last few fine cuts off with a freshly sharpened gouge. If the wood is too soft for that approach, then you try a proprietary brand of wood hardener....you can get Ronseal wet rot wood hardener from Screwfix, and it is very good, works in seconds.
Les