the AT Axminster lathe has the same swing as your current lathe,the 1628 looks like a great lathe and has the extra 2 ins of swing over your lathe,but has 33 x 3.5mm thread on the spindle instead of 1" x 8 of yours,the record only has a 12 " swing,but will swivel out to do bigger bowls than the AT can,I`d go for the 1628 personaly,given a choice of those three lathes,when I upgraded from my CCVBL 1100 or the AWVSL 1000 as they now call it,I went for a Jet 3520B,but that no doubt will be miles out of your price range if a 1628 is haha.