Andy,
from the top down;
The finial is amazing, after delicate turned ones, I really love to see natural items being used, The antler really works in this instance.
The pyro texture and colours are certainly 'in your face', red and black are two colours that have always worked well together for me and they do so here. I've asked before what your Red is and not been told, I might have to come peak in your workshop sometime!
The form - sorry, to my eye it looks unbalanced, the curve below the lid becomes too flat and then sits 'out-of-kilter' with the lid itself. To put it in my parlance - the curve is off.